Video Game Mafia Thread

[GM Eli]

Great game. Tons of fun. Arguing with Franchise will always be the most infuriating thing on the planet lol, but especially when you're telling the truth and no one is listening because your early game reads were poor.

Glad Doug made the math save.

I think the abilities between both scum and town were fairly balanced. The only thing I would change would be to have allowed Franchise a night kill toward the end. Leaving him completely sorta defenseless during the final night few night phases was tough. But that's being nitpicky about an otherwise really great game.

[GM Franchise]

Great game. I still can't believe they voted you out over me, Eli. If I had a night kill at the end it would've been interesting to see how it would play out.

[GM Dougie]

In our Mason area, Oldfield was convinced you were scum Eli. And I had to hold it against you when you argued against Ganon being scum. You weren't wrong at all based on what was out there but I could imagine a scum teammate doing that.

And you were thinking I was scum a lot so OMGUS all the way. LOL

I enjoyed the game. Definitely had solid balance. My complaint was the vote math when there was only 4 needed for 8 ppl or 3 needed for 6 ppl which are not traditional majorities but its also not my game and I shouldn't be snarky.

Thank you!

[GM Lucas]

This helps, I thought if I didn't stay consistent with dropping the vote down by one every phase people might think I was manipulating it for results. But next time i'll do

10/6
9/5
8/5
7/4
6/4
5/3
4/3
3/2

Def have to also make assassinating at night for scum more of a thing

[GM Pancho]

Personally I'm going to take complete credit for this town win - YOU ARE WELCOME!!

In reality solid town moves to info dump WHEN it happened.

Kirk coming out and laying everything out. Then Eli timely info dump really helped Doug put 2 and 2 together [See what I did there].

I've voiced my opinion to Ed on the vote thing and also essentially letting the write ups act as town cops when the character claims started coming out but for what I believe was a first time game set up - KUDOS!

[GM Kirk]

I couldn't believe you guys took out Eli instead of Franchise. I was back and forth on them until the character claims doomed Powers (well deserved MVP for Doug) but thought it was obvious which was scum after that. I liked my post restriction because it forced me to read closely and be decisive. If the mafia had been less cautious, they could have won the game with 8 players left. There were town votes on town players, so all they had to do was all 3 jump on one and save Fosters. Then with 6 left they would have half the votes. The number to get a lynch could have been a game breaker.

[GM Kirk]

I also should have said it was a fun game with entertaining write-ups and interesting roles. Good game overall and mostly good natured as well.