avatar_GM Eli

Another Secret Hitler - BLUE 4 RED 4 - SECRET HITLER ELECTED, FASCISTS WIN

Started by GM Eli, February 17, 2023, 06:41:43 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 3 Guests are viewing this topic.

GM Pancho

I was given three reds. No choice in any of the matter and as promised I elected franchise.

GM Dougie

That makes Franchise president twice in a row. I don't know if that was such a bright idea.

GM Pancho

IMO short of me - he has the strongest liberal leanings having passed me a blue policy and played one himself. We can always vote against his government if you are displeased.

GM Franchise

Quote from: GM Dougie on February 25, 2023, 01:38:43 PM
That makes Franchise president twice in a row. I don't know if that was such a bright idea.

I think the cards will play a bigger factor considering that if some of the cards were lied about that's going to come into play in these turns. But as Pancho said you can always vote against the government if you don't like it.

GM Mike Powers

Franchise, who would you kill if your government produces a red policy?

GM Franchise

Quote from: GM Mike Powers on February 25, 2023, 02:54:29 PM
Franchise, who would you kill if your government produces a red policy?

We've had two red policies passed and both said three reds were given to them so it would be probably be Doug since I'm positive Pancho is a liberal going by how the game has gone on.


GM Franchise

Quote from: GM Oldfield on February 25, 2023, 04:11:46 PM
Why franchise?

Pancho and Doug have been presidents that passed red policies. I think Pancho is liberal so process of elimination. Unless someone can figure out if anyone was lying about the cards they said that's the most logical route to go.

Talon


Talon

I agree that Doug is the most suspect, to me.  Obviously he would have an ally and a secret hitler out there to support but I currently would not support any government with Doug in it.

if I HAD to choose outside of that I would also shy away from an Oldfield govt, but its just a hunch.

GM Dougie

Oldfield has been in 2 red policy governments (yes one was mine) and possibly lied about cards early on. He's probably the only sure Fascist right now.

Pancho is the only sure thing at liberal.

GM Franchise

Quote from: GM Dougie on February 25, 2023, 06:52:15 PM
Oldfield has been in 2 red policy governments (yes one was mine) and possibly lied about cards early on. He's probably the only sure Fascist right now.

Pancho is the only sure thing at liberal.

Agreed about all of this. I'm leaning Powers for President.

GM Oldfield

So despite knowing Doug that on one of my red policies you handed me two policies you've labelled me a 'guaranteed facist'?

GM Franchise

Quote from: GM Oldfield on February 26, 2023, 01:57:24 AM
So despite knowing Doug that on one of my red policies you handed me two policies you've labelled me a 'guaranteed facist'?

Good point.

I'm nominating Powers for President.


Talon


GM Franchise


GM Mike Powers


GM Eli

Vote Tally for Franchise/Powers

Yes - 3
No - 1

Deadline for voting will be tomorrow (2/27) at 9am Eastern Standard Time

GM Mike Powers


GM Fosters

I think it's a terrible idea to have someone be president twice in a row. So I'm voting no.

Vote no

Talon


GM Eli

The deadline has passed and the Franchise/Powers government has failed.

Given that Franchise was named President by Special election, the power returns to the normal order and Franchise is once again president.

Please nominate a chancellor. Powers is ineligible to be chosen.

GM Pancho

Damn I missed deadline. At least I'm eligible now.

GM Franchise

Quote from: GM Pancho on February 27, 2023, 09:42:06 AM
Damn I missed deadline. At least I'm eligible now.

Yep and speaking of that I nominate Pancho.

GM Mike Powers

Something fishy about that stalled government.

GM Franchise

Quote from: GM Mike Powers on February 27, 2023, 10:59:12 AM
Something fishy about that stalled government.

Yeah and also Doug avoided the responding to Oldfield. Don't know if it's related but it's something I took note of.

Talon


Talon

Concerned Pancho is Hitler, skips the vote, conveniently now eligible. 

Yeah VOTE NO

GM Pancho

Quote from: Talon on February 27, 2023, 11:53:23 AM
Concerned Pancho is Hitler, skips the vote, conveniently now eligible. 

Yeah VOTE NO

Never attribute to malice that which can be adequately explained by stupidity.

GM Pancho



GM Dougie

I was apparently supposed to respond to something earlier and I got busy this weekend.

I acknowledged one of the two governments was mine that you got the red on. My point was you were also in another red government. Its weak but I don't have much else to go on in terms of people I'd avoid putting in office.

Talon's no vote is hysterical.

Vote: Yes

GM Mike Powers

Doug, why'd you vote no on me/Franchise?

GM Dougie

Quote from: GM Dougie on February 25, 2023, 01:38:43 PM
That makes Franchise president twice in a row. I don't know if that was such a bright idea.

GM Oldfield

Vote yes

Sorry been distracted today. Doug voted no and he's my biggest suspect right now for how he jumps on the attack when it's convenient. Tbf he's the only one I have even a slight inclination about

Talon

Doug, Pancho, and Oldfield with Pancho as hitler is my guess.

But I dont think its going to matter.

GM Eli

Government has been confirmed. Please hold.

GM Eli

#138
The government has met and have enacted a...

Fascist Policy


As a result of a 4th fascist policy being played, the kill ability has been activated for the president and DOUG has been chosen for execution.

With 6 players remaining, a 4 vote majority is still required to confirm the government. Oldfield is now president. Franchise and Pancho are ineligible to be nominated as chancellor. Talking may resume.

GM Pancho

Quote from: Talon on February 27, 2023, 05:46:09 PM
Doug, Pancho, and Oldfield with Pancho as hitler is my guess.

But I dont think its going to matter.




GM Pancho


GM Franchise

Yet again we get 3 reds. Something isn't adding up with the cards going by what I received.

GM Oldfield


GM Eli

Quote from: GM Oldfield on February 27, 2023, 06:26:49 PM
Do we not find out what Doug was?

If the executed
player is not Hitler, the table
should not learn whether a Fascist or
a Liberal has been killed

Talon

Doesn't mean I'm not right about the rest...

I didn't think Pancho until he no showed the vote and was immediately being nominated just felt off.

I didn't realize we got no reveal on the kill, ouch.

GM Pancho

Quote from: Talon on February 27, 2023, 07:02:02 PM
Doesn't mean I'm not right about the rest...

I didn't think Pancho until he no showed the vote and was immediately being nominated just felt off.

I didn't realize we got no reveal on the kill, ouch.

I at least respect you being public about your reads.

But others were equally publicly suspicious of Douglas. Obviously influenced Franchise. For the record I was too but I'm curiously analyzing as if I was both right and wrong.

Id like to know what Oldfield reads are but the rest of the group as well. One thing we can all agree on is I am not Hitler. I have the added information that I am liberal but y'all cannot be sure - but I hope my play continues to back that assertion.

Talon

At this point I have no reason not to believe you, if you are a fascist in the end, it's just a job well done. I'll support any Pancho government as long as I trust the man passing him the cards.

I am not sure I'll support an Oldfield government in any fashion this time around unless I am convinced.

GM Oldfield

Problem I have right now is that Talon could be right (except about me), I could be right, Pancho could be right. Any choice is a risk right now except someone we've had who's def not hitler but I can't choose Pancho.

Nominate Talon

My only thought is maybe talon and I are coming at it from two different angles

GM Franchise


GM Pancho

Quote from: GM Oldfield on February 28, 2023, 02:39:36 AM
Problem I have right now is that Talon could be right (except about me), I could be right, Pancho could be right. Any choice is a risk right now except someone we've had who's def not hitler but I can't choose Pancho.

Nominate Talon

My only thought is maybe talon and I are coming at it from two different angles

Vote: No