Video Game Mafia Thread

[GM Dougie]

You mean the post where I was suspicious about someone asking for detailed information early in the game?

Yes but not the whole thing. Just this sentence:

"Someone could easily lie about their information and probably will which is why I'm not doing it."

Just a little off put by that is all. At this second not enough to make it worth a vote or anything. I'm processing Kirk's posts and the reactions to it as there was little else anything to go off of day 1

[GM Eli]

Not sure how I feel about the vote being this split early on in the day phase. I'm going to guess that at least one of the three people that have voted are scum but no idea which one.

Kirk putting it out there that he was targeted and that his role was exposed seems pretty straightforward to me so I'm not sure what all there is to unpack, or why he's getting jumped on as Scum. I'm with Franchise in that that stood out to me. But tbf Josh did give a decent explanation as to why he's leaning that way. I'm just not sure I'm ready to vote for Kirk based off that yet.

[GM Bennett]

You've been just as quiet as me Oldfield.

This is a lie. Stevie actually made post after checking in. You didn't say anything at all for the full day until I placed a vote on you.



I'm not sure how I exactly I feel bout Kirk's strong claim. I also don't want to completely dismiss it either. This is a new game and I'm not gonna sit here and try to "mod the mod" if that's an advantage he has given to others in this game. Kirk doesn't paint me as a guy that would just flat out say that for no reason though honestly.

I can see why one could read Franchise's post and think he's a definite suspect for Pancho/Snake's death. Wouldn't be surprised if that's what scum wants us to think as well.

All that said keeping my eyes on Fosters, Kirk and Franchise for the most part. I don't have much of a read or gut feeling about anyone really but with the recent stuff this is the way i'm looking.

I'd want Kirk to expand more on why he chose Powers, Doug and Josh specifically as to why that's who he suspects. Back reading from day one I really don't understand it. If his post restriction claim is true then I wouldn't imagine him responding asap personally.

[GM Franchise]

You've been just as quiet as me Oldfield.

This is a lie. Stevie actually made post after checking in. You didn't say anything at all for the full day until I placed a vote on you.



I'm not sure how I exactly I feel bout Kirk's strong claim. I also don't want to completely dismiss it either. This is a new game and I'm not gonna sit here and try to "mod the mod" if that's an advantage he has given to others in this game. Kirk doesn't paint me as a guy that would just flat out say that for no reason though honestly.

I can see why one could read Franchise's post and think he's a definite suspect for Pancho/Snake's death. Wouldn't be surprised if that's what scum wants us to think as well.

All that said keeping my eyes on Fosters, Kirk and Franchise for the most part. I don't have much of a read or gut feeling about anyone really but with the recent stuff this is the way i'm looking.

I'd want Kirk to expand more on why he chose Powers, Doug and Josh specifically as to why that's who he suspects. Back reading from day one I really don't understand it. If his post restriction claim is true then I wouldn't imagine him responding asap personally.

I get that about my post but I'm also the perfect fall guy for that too considering I was about the only one who got into it with Pancho before he got killed. The fact that it wasn't brought up and it's just "I've got eyes on Franchise" from a few people is mind boggling. It's likely one of the people saying that who killed Pancho in my opinion.

[GM Bennett]

Which is why I'm exactly sold on the idea just curious atm

[GM Bennett]

Which is why I'm exactly sold on the idea just curious atm

why I'm NOT** exactly sold

[GM Lucas]

VOTE COUNT
Powers - 1 -(Kirk)
Kirk - 1 - (Josh)
Fosters - 1- (Oldfield)

NOT VOTING-EVERYONE ELSE

YOU HAVE UNTIL 3:00 PM EST, Wednesday, February 9th (40 hours) , TO REACH A LYNCH. WITH 9 PLAYERS ALIVE IT WILL TAKE 5 TO LYNCH

DO NOT POST AFTER WEDNESDAY 3PM EST

[GM Josh]

Franchise my suspicion of you is less to do with your pay and more to do with Kirk. His entire post just came across as a quick way to try and avoid having anyone target him except somehow just The Godfather, also odd that he would know it's The Godfather. The fact that he left you off his list of suspects when saying it had to be one of the older players puts you in a bad light but can also be seen as scum trying to use you as a fall guy when Kirk flips. Just feel it would be good to keep a fast eye on you.

You mean the post where I was suspicious about someone asking for detailed information early in the game?

Yes but not the whole thing. Just this sentence:

"Someone could easily lie about their information and probably will which is why I'm not doing it."

Just a little off put by that is all. At this second not enough to make it worth a vote or anything. I'm processing Kirk's posts and the reactions to it as there was little else anything to go off of day 1

[GM Josh]

EBWOP

ignore the quote portion, I think I hit that by accident when I dropped my phone lol

[GM Kirk]

I didn't mention Franchise because he's an agent of chaos and the mafia going after me and Pancho is the mark of a methodical player. That's not to say Franchise isn't a member of the mafia, but I don't think he's the one pulling the strings.

I was told that the godfather himself bypassed my role and that my role was exposed. Not those exact words but I don't want to fall too close to quoting the mod. I assume it's like a strongman type deal. Josh's responses to this particular detail strike me as someone annoyed that their action was exposed. That's something for you to take up with the mod after the game.

Unvote
Vote: Josh

I generally try to avoid OMGUS votes, but Josh's reply seem like someone who knows they can't kill me and understands that the only way to get rid of me is to lynch me as soon as possible.

That's all I have for today. Unfortunately I must be spartan with my posts, but I've laid everything out and trust the rest of you to take it from here.

[GM Fosters]

My strongest town read so far is Kirk. I really don't think he'd make up a post restriction. I'd go out on a limb and say I'm almost certain he's Town.

Franchise. I can never tell.

Doug- I'm leaning towards Town for... but he's a clever player and fooled me before.

I get the impression Eli is Town.

Bennett- I'm not liking the way he's come across, voting with no or little justification. But he did make some good points in his last post.

Oldfield- you posted one more thing than I did and it was a shitty joke about Kevin... so I'd get off your high horse.

Powers is a crafty one and has been extremely quiet... would be typical of him to go after the stronger more experienced players as Kirk said... FOS but I'll give him benefit of the doubt for now.

Josh is coming across as scum to me. I think he's possibly over reading the information Kirk has given and trying to press an agenda.

For that reason

Vote Josh

[GM Oldfield]

I don't feel Josh is scum. I think he's fixated on one aspect of kirks post which he's done in previous games. I'm not sure why not lumping franchise with Powers, himself and Kirk is so strange to you Josh.

My biggest issue at the moment is I feel Kirk, Josh and Doug are all town but are all targeting each other, and those three players with their personalities are going to probably end up splitting the vote enough to fail to get a lynch.

Also, can we all vote Fosters early day 3 because he only seems to wake up once he's had a vote and it would be useful to get his perspective early on

[GM Franchise]

Franchise my suspicion of you is less to do with your pay and more to do with Kirk. His entire post just came across as a quick way to try and avoid having anyone target him except somehow just The Godfather, also odd that he would know it's The Godfather. The fact that he left you off his list of suspects when saying it had to be one of the older players puts you in a bad light but can also be seen as scum trying to use you as a fall guy when Kirk flips. Just feel it would be good to keep a fast eye on you.

You mean the post where I was suspicious about someone asking for detailed information early in the game?

Yes but not the whole thing. Just this sentence:

"Someone could easily lie about their information and probably will which is why I'm not doing it."

Just a little off put by that is all. At this second not enough to make it worth a vote or anything. I'm processing Kirk's posts and the reactions to it as there was little else anything to go off of day 1

So your suspicion of me is because of someone else? That's weak as fuck reasoning right there. Secondly Kirk probably has that info in his role PM so questioning that is kinda meh to me. I'd vote for you right now but something else caught my eye.

Fosters, you said Josh was trying to push an agenda but clearly so are you with your post. Explain to me how your post is different than what you voted Josh for doing?

I will be voting for Fosters or Josh this day phase. Not going to rush it but at least one of them is scum going by what I'm seeing.

[GM Lucas]

VOTE COUNT
Josh - 2 -(Kirk, Fosters)
Kirk - 1 - (Josh)
Fosters - 1- (Oldfield)

NOT VOTING-EVERYONE ELSE

YOU HAVE UNTIL 3:00 PM EST, Wednesday, February 9th (26 1/2 hours) , TO REACH A LYNCH. WITH 9 PLAYERS ALIVE IT WILL TAKE 5 TO LYNCH
DO NOT POST AFTER WEDNESDAY 3PM EST

[GM Mike Powers]

Blatant activity post here. I'm at work right now, but I plan on catching up tonight when I get home and posting my thoughts.

[GM Dougie]

We're already 24 hours from deadline. Would be nice to get things sorted.

I'll tell you that based on those who currently have votes I am not voting for Kirk. Ultimately, his strategy is aggressive and more likely town than scum. Not impossible to be scum but when we make reads we have to pick a side and I'm choosing to believe he's doing it as town.

I'm not opposed to a Fosters or Josh vote and am willing to be swayed to which one is best. Josh's quick reaction to Kirk doesn't make him necessarily scum. I've seen players (myself included) who focus in on one player.

Fosters hasn't done much. He's not the only one so its unfair that its the biggest thing against him. Powers literally just made an activity post.

Its only day 2 but its easy for scum to lay low because no lynches will make their job take longer but also easier so hopefully we ultimately go in the right direction today.

[GM Bennett]

VOTE: JOSH

Basing this off of Kirk's post along with what Josh said in his own post. If he was so suspicious of Kirk himself being scum and being The Godfather, it doesn't make sense for him not to place a vote on him and rather place a vote on someone else.

With Kirk putting himself on the line the way he is, I'm going to take his word for it now. This is a double edge sword type of action of him to do though so if we do get a lynch on Josh and he flips he's part of the town who is legitimately trying to save Kevin, then I will for sure place my vote on him no matter what he tries to say to defend himself.

Bennett- I'm not liking the way he's come across, voting with no or little justification. But he did make some good points in his last post.

I would think voting for someone not being active at all is justification enough. Scum tend to try and chill in the background and not be that active to not raise any alarm or suspicions on themselves. That's what I noticed with you on Day 1 which has led me to be suspicious of you going forward in this game.

[GM Mike Powers]

I was investigated by the godfather, apparently. My role was exposed so might as well out it here. I can't be targeted at night (except by the godfather it seems), but I also can only make two posts per day. So mafia targets night 1 were Pancho and myself, which points me towards guys from back in the day.

Vote: Powers

Powers, Doug and Josh are the guys I'm thinking of for godfather, but I can't narrow it down from there.

I find Kirks role to be odd. He is untargetable, but also gets told role information on who visits him AND has a post restriction? Very weird to me, but I'm not gonna mod the mod and use that as a reason to vote.

Interesting that Kirk feels that the targets are based around the old batch of Mafia players but leaves out Franchise. Also can't be targeted at night except by GF which typically doesn't have any additional roles outside of making the kill if needed. Seems like a quick ploy to avoid someone from watching after the cop was killed as well.

vote: Kirk

FOS: Franchise as Kirks post reads like a way of diverting attention from him as well.

This reads as town to me. Josh hasn't played a ton of mafia over here, and is using his knowledge of old EFK/MFX meta to build on. I'm not sure I buy it, but it feels town motivated.

A lot to process,

I don't want to get into a debate about the mechanics of the godfather. That's no ether here nor there.

Bennett's post screams a pointless activity one to me, but he's consistently brought the flavour of the game into other previous mafia games, so I don't feel ready to lynch him but my eyes are on him.

Powers targeting Kirk and Pancho day 1 is just too obvious. But the biggest red flag for me right now is Fosters quietness, so that's where I'm going.

VOte Fosters

This reads like a fluff post, not amounting to much.....until he inexplicably brings heat on Fosters. Scum trying to push an agenda, or Oldfield perhaps being subtle about some info he gained in the night?

I need to pause on Kirk. There's a lot to unpack but he's using specific language in that post that makes me hold off on just not believing it. The whole godfather targeted me thing is questionable I need some time on that one.

There was also something Franchise posted before the end of the day phase that hit my radar. I'll have to go back and re-read later before any callouts.

You mean the post where I was suspicious about someone asking for detailed information early in the game?

Yes but not the whole thing. Just this sentence:

"Someone could easily lie about their information and probably will which is why I'm not doing it."

Just a little off put by that is all. At this second not enough to make it worth a vote or anything. I'm processing Kirk's posts and the reactions to it as there was little else anything to go off of day 1

We're already 24 hours from deadline. Would be nice to get things sorted.

I'll tell you that based on those who currently have votes I am not voting for Kirk. Ultimately, his strategy is aggressive and more likely town than scum. Not impossible to be scum but when we make reads we have to pick a side and I'm choosing to believe he's doing it as town.

I'm not opposed to a Fosters or Josh vote and am willing to be swayed to which one is best. Josh's quick reaction to Kirk doesn't make him necessarily scum. I've seen players (myself included) who focus in on one player.

Fosters hasn't done much. He's not the only one so its unfair that its the biggest thing against him. Powers literally just made an activity post.

Its only day 2 but its easy for scum to lay low because no lynches will make their job take longer but also easier so hopefully we ultimately go in the right direction today.

I appreciate the discourse, but Doug is riding the fence HARD here.

My strongest town read so far is Kirk. I really don't think he'd make up a post restriction. I'd go out on a limb and say I'm almost certain he's Town.

Franchise. I can never tell.

Doug- I'm leaning towards Town for... but he's a clever player and fooled me before.

I get the impression Eli is Town.

Bennett- I'm not liking the way he's come across, voting with no or little justification. But he did make some good points in his last post.

Oldfield- you posted one more thing than I did and it was a shitty joke about Kevin... so I'd get off your high horse.

Powers is a crafty one and has been extremely quiet... would be typical of him to go after the stronger more experienced players as Kirk said... FOS but I'll give him benefit of the doubt for now.

Josh is coming across as scum to me. I think he's possibly over reading the information Kirk has given and trying to press an agenda.

For that reason

Vote Josh

This is probably Fosters' best post in a mafia game ever. I disagree with his reads, quite a bit actually. Josh is town to me.

VOTE: JOSH

Basing this off of Kirk's post along with what Josh said in his own post. If he was so suspicious of Kirk himself being scum and being The Godfather, it doesn't make sense for him not to place a vote on him and rather place a vote on someone else.

With Kirk putting himself on the line the way he is, I'm going to take his word for it now. This is a double edge sword type of action of him to do though so if we do get a lynch on Josh and he flips he's part of the town who is legitimately trying to save Kevin, then I will for sure place my vote on him no matter what he tries to say to defend himself.

Bennett- I'm not liking the way he's come across, voting with no or little justification. But he did make some good points in his last post.

I would think voting for someone not being active at all is justification enough. Scum tend to try and chill in the background and not be that active to not raise any alarm or suspicions on themselves. That's what I noticed with you on Day 1 which has led me to be suspicious of you going forward in this game.

The steam is building on a Josh lynch, one that I think is waaay off the mark. At least one person on it has to be scum. I'm gonna go with Fosters. His post is organized and unlike him in previous games. I'm guessing someone guided/coached him a bit to keep him from getting early heat.

Vote Fosters

[GM Lucas]

VOTE COUNT
Josh - 3 -(Kirk, Fosters, Bennett)
Kirk - 1 - (Josh)
Fosters - 2- (Oldfield, Powers)

NOT VOTING-EVERYONE ELSE

YOU HAVE UNTIL 3:00 PM EST, Wednesday, February 9th (18 hours) , TO REACH A LYNCH. WITH 9 PLAYERS ALIVE IT WILL TAKE 5 TO LYNCH
DO NOT POST AFTER WEDNESDAY 3PM EST

[GM Eli]

There's some things that have stood out to me but for the time being I'm going to keep most of them to myself.

A couple of things, though, that I think are notable. First, Doug does seem to be sitting on the fence a bit, and he's typically a pretty strong player. And the other is that both Powers and Oldfield jumped on the Fosters train for reasons that are a big inexplicable to me. One for "quietness" when Oldfield hasn't been overly engaged himself, and the other for having organized thoughts?? Just odd from where I'm sitting.

For the time being I find Kirks information, and the aggressiveness with which he put it out there, to be the strongest town play and Josh doesn't seem to be responding like town who is desperate to stay alive. So.

Vote: Josh

[GM Oldfield]

I don't think anyone has been particularly busy on this game, including you Eli. It's a slow burner this one. But when you only engage and get involved after someone's voted for you (Bennett day 1, and myself day 2) it comes us overly defensive.

[GM Oldfield]

That being said I feel we really a lynch. And although I am not 100% convinced, I can see your argument for Josh. It just reminds me of when two town end up arguing.

Unvote

Vote Josh

[GM Dougie]

Sitting on the fence because I want to make sure I'm making the right vote. Hate that callout by Powers. Would vote him but he's not getting lynched today.

Eli's point about Josh is valid. In past games as a town member wrongfully getting lynched he defends himself a lot more. That and if I'm scum-reading Powers, him not voting Josh is a vote split.

So I guess voting Josh is the best way to go today.

Vote: Josh

[GM Franchise]

Vote: Josh

Was hoping to hear back from Josh and Fosters before voting but that clearly isn't happening. I agree with Doug about Powers' vote post as well.

[GM Lucas]

WE HAVE REACHED A LYNCH. HOLD FOR WRITE UP

[GM Lucas]

As the group becomes unsettled and starts to react to the death of Solid Snake, the finger pointing begins. Sonic the Hedge Hog decides to take the leadership role and point out that Solid Snake had left the group to follow her. He points at Princess Zelda.

Sonic:Why, why was he following you. What did you do to him?

Zelda: Does it look like I am wielding a sword Sonic.

Sonic: Why did you become his target.

Zelda: What are you implying my dear Sonic, Let's take a moment and realize you are by far the fastest, you can move around without anyone one of us noticing. Who would be able to kill someone and not be seen by any of us? YOU! no one else here has your speed, your ability to move in the shadows and you know this terrain very well considering your days of battling Dr Robotnick in your home world. Let's not forget, you are the only holding the wooden sword we got from the merchant.

Sonic: You live in Hyrule, I wouldn't talk about surroundings. I also got the sword because I am the one going out the furthest to check the perimeter. I traveled the perimeter looking for clues just like the rest of you.

Sonic finds himself  Surrounded.

Zelda: Who sent you?

Sonic's left leg is taken out from under him to stop him from running.

Cloud: Sorry my blue friend, but we cannot risk someone with your speed and ability walking, or running among us. Upon hearing the agonizing scream from Snake as he took his last breath you could have gotten to him within seconds to see who killed him, unless you are the one who killed him and got away fast enough for none of us to see. Not even the princess who he followed saw anything, but yet you are the one holding the sword.

The crowd closes in on Sonic as he lets out a scream for help as the crowd mercifully beats him to death. The glimmer from Sonic's eyes dim as he points to the distance, then falls face first to the ground, THEN SILENCE!

The crowd moves away. Neither member looking happy about having to take Sonic out. They walk away leaving Sonic dead on the ground

DEAD: JOSH-SONIC THE HEDGE HOG (VANILLA TOWN)

NO TALKING. IT IS NOW NIGHTTIME. PLEASE SEND ALL YOUR ACTIONS THROUGH DM OR DISCORD

DEADLINE IS FRIDAY AT 5pm EST (52 HOURS) OR UNTIL ALL NIGHT ACTIONS ARE SENT IN

[GM Lucas]

With tensions rising, the thought of sleeping while someone kept watch was not even suggested. Instead, the group decided to they would walk in a staggered formation in order to keep watch from all sides. The sun begins to rise. At the very back Mario hears the snapping of twigs as if he is being followed. He looks around and notices a shadow from behind a tree, he calls for the group to stop.

The group prepares for the unknown as Out from behind the tree stumbles one of Bowsers pesky nephews, Iggy Koopa.

(NPC)Iggy: You will never find Kevin, My uncle will make sure that my brothers, sister and I sabotage this entire mission of yours. Videoland will be ours, then next stop, EARTH

Cloud reaches for his sword but finds that it's not on his back in its sheath. Iggy runs through the bushes and manages to get away as Mario attempts to follow but knows not to wonder to far after him for that it could be a trap.

Cloud looks around and notices his sword up on a tree. Baffled as to how it got off his back and up into the tree. Link offers a hand as both characters manage to get back Cloud's sword.

The sun is finally up and the group once again makes their way towards the castle at the end of the forrest.  

IT IS NOW DAY 3. WITH 8 ALIVE IT TAKES 4 TO LYNCH. YOU HAVE UNTIL MONDAY FEBRUARY 14TH, 12PM EST TO REACH A LYNCH. DO NOT POST AFTER DEADLINE

[GM Bennett]

Keeping my word.

VOTE: KIRK

[GM Dougie]

Game is far too quiet to start this phase and with Super Bowl weekend (and a child being born) I anticipate inactivity.

I want to vote Powers but logically the association isn't there as he was against voting Josh regardless of the flip.

No kill. One theory is that scum could have tested Kirk's claim by targeting him. That would make the assumption Kirk is town.

Another theory is scum Kirk and the no kill just basically there was some fuckery that prevented it.

Looking at everyone who voted for Josh (Franchise doesn't count Josh had enough votes before his), I can see it being a scum driven wagon after Kirk voting Josh and scum knowing Josh was town it was an easy start. So aside from myself that's Fosters, Bennett, Eli, and Oldfield for 1-2 scum is my prediction.

Before anyone attempts to point out how quickly the hammer came, after Oldfield's vote, I think logically its too risky to do that if Oldfield and I were a scum team. I think its more likely that its one of the early votes Fosters or Bennett.

Vote: Fosters

[GM Fosters]

I've really got no idea why there was no kill last night.

Despite Josh flipping town, I still get the impression that Kirk, Doug and Eli are Town.

Everyone else... I wouldn't want to put much money on whether they are scum or town. We do really need to lynch scum this day phase.

I could get behind a Bennett, Oldfield, Franchise or Powers vote.

[GM Mike Powers]

Game is far too quiet to start this phase and with Super Bowl weekend (and a child being born) I anticipate inactivity.

I want to vote Powers but logically the association isn't there as he was against voting Josh regardless of the flip.

No kill. One theory is that scum could have tested Kirk's claim by targeting him. That would make the assumption Kirk is town.

Another theory is scum Kirk and the no kill just basically there was some fuckery that prevented it.

Looking at everyone who voted for Josh (Franchise doesn't count Josh had enough votes before his), I can see it being a scum driven wagon after Kirk voting Josh and scum knowing Josh was town it was an easy start. So aside from myself that's Fosters, Bennett, Eli, and Oldfield for 1-2 scum is my prediction.

Before anyone attempts to point out how quickly the hammer came, after Oldfield's vote, I think logically its too risky to do that if Oldfield and I were a scum team. I think its more likely that its one of the early votes Fosters or Bennett.

Vote: Fosters

Not sure why I'm rubbing you the wrong way. I (correctly) stated that you were riding the fence, but didn't call it a scum tell or anything like that.

Anyways, you have the right idea on Fosters, I'm 100% in on that.

Vote Fosters

Another person I'm keeping my eye on is Bennett - his "keeping my word" vote is pretty weak sauce to start a new day phase.

[GM Franchise]

My thinking is very similar to Doug's on this. I think it was a scum driven wagon but not sure who to go for but Fosters is who I'm leaking towards.

I've really got no idea why there was no kill last night.

Despite Josh flipping town, I still get the impression that Kirk, Doug and Eli are Town.

Everyone else... I wouldn't want to put much money on whether they are scum or town. We do really need to lynch scum this day phase.

I could get behind a Bennett, Oldfield, Franchise or Powers vote.

So get behind votes for half the players left to get the heat off of yourself? That's how that last part reads to me.

[GM Oldfield]

Josh being town sort of makes me almost certain He's town.

Kirk has played a, rather unique card, and there's no reason to doubt him being town at this stage.

Anyone else could be scum, but the one who I have the strongest feeling about right now is Fosters. I know I been ultra critical considering everyone (including me) but there's just too many comments he's made that has made me doubt his town affiliation.

Vote Fosters

[GM Eli]

I'm the most wary of those who hopped on the vote at the end that saw Josh get lynched. I think we'd all be willing to bet money that at least one of them is scum, if not more than that. I know that I'm town, but the other three (Doug, Franchise and Oldfield) I get varying levels of scum vibes from. That said, I can see why people would be unsure of me also, as I was also on the vote at the end that lead to getting Josh lynched. But I am town. Here's my reasoning for the other three.

Doug's fence sitting during the previous day phase still stands out to me, and even more interesting is the fact that he's decisive in his vote for Fosters today after he "wasn't opposed" to a Fosters and Josh vote and then had Josh flip town.

Franchise for me is just too much "I agree with what Doug said" recently.

Oldfield is probably the one I have the least scum vibes about. But because he was technically the hammer (I believe) I think some suspicion has to be cast upon him as well.

[GM Mike Powers]

Josh being town sort of makes me almost certain He's town.

Kirk has played a, rather unique card, and there's no reason to doubt him being town at this stage.

Anyone else could be scum, but the one who I have the strongest feeling about right now is Fosters. I know I been ultra critical considering everyone (including me) but there's just too many comments he's made that has made me doubt his town affiliation.

Vote Fosters

^^^

Driving that bus already? I would've thought you'd have Bennett do that.

[GM Kirk]

I agree with Eli. I don't like Doug and Oldfield together on Josh and then Fosters. They could be working together, or Oldfield is piggy backing Doug.

[GM Franchise]

Josh being town sort of makes me almost certain He's town.

Kirk has played a, rather unique card, and there's no reason to doubt him being town at this stage.

Anyone else could be scum, but the one who I have the strongest feeling about right now is Fosters. I know I been ultra critical considering everyone (including me) but there's just too many comments he's made that has made me doubt his town affiliation.

Vote Fosters

^^^

Driving that bus already? I would've thought you'd have Bennett do that.

You're on the Fosters wagon, too. Let's not forget about that either.

[GM Dougie]

Lol Eli is scum. Great post that really helps. I was indecisive yesterday... of the 2 choices one is gone. It's not a difficult decision today.

Possible 3 person scum team: Fosters, Eli, Bennett. Bookmark this post.

Ok carry on.

----

P.S. I see a trend with really close timestamps between Oldfield and I. Anyone playing off that is TERRIBLE town play. Like the time y'all used Kirk on China time. The ONLY time that matters is at LYLO and scum are getting a win. Awful awful and I may be inclined to bitch about that post-game.

And as for Franchise. He either agrees with you or argues with you. Always. That's not abnormal. He's a way better player than he gets credit for because he always sticks to his meta

[GM Dougie]

Notice how I didn't accuse of it.  I suggested it.

Put words in my mouth I dare you

[GM Bennett]

Looking at everyone who voted for Josh (Franchise doesn't count Josh had enough votes before his), I can see it being a scum driven wagon after Kirk voting Josh and scum knowing Josh was town it was an easy start. So aside from myself that's Fosters, Bennett, Eli, and Oldfield for 1-2 scum is my prediction.
Vote: Fosters

Everyone else... I wouldn't want to put much money on whether they are scum or town. We do really need to lynch scum this day phase.

I could get behind a Bennett, Oldfield, Franchise or Powers vote.

Another person I'm keeping my eye on is Bennett - his "keeping my word" vote is pretty weak sauce to start a new day phase.

^^^

Driving that bus already? I would've thought you'd have Bennett do that.

Yes me saying I'm keeping my word is so weak sauce that I'm featured in two voting post and last night's write up that makes it seem me and someone else was targeted and potentially protected last night. Real smart there, Mike. Makes me raise an eyebrow towards you with your sudden hard on for me.

I said I'd do exactly what it is I said I would do, and that's what I am doing. If I were to go against what I said I was gonna do I'd be voting for the person I've been the most suspicious of this game.

[GM Eli]

Notice how I didn't accuse of it.  I suggested it.

Put words in my mouth I dare you

The last time I can remember Doug getting this aggressive about someone casting doubt on him in game (it was me) he turned around and lead a lynch on me when I was town (like I am in this game, regardless of what he LOL's about) and ended up winning as scum.

I wasn't sold before this sequence of posts, just had suspicions. I'm sold now.

Vote: Doug

[GM Oldfield]

It's great this game has sparked into life but could people stop quoting quotes within quotes it's impossible to follow.

Ducking Quoteception

[GM Dougie]

The last time I can remember Doug getting this aggressive about someone casting doubt on him in game (it was me) he turned around and lead a lynch on me when I was town (like I am in this game, regardless of what he LOL's about) and ended up winning as scum.

And the last time you voted for someone based on how they played a previous game (Josh) you were wrong. I followed your logic. I won't again.

Or you're scum. Which I keep believing with every post you make.

[GM Mike Powers]

Josh being town sort of makes me almost certain He's town.

Kirk has played a, rather unique card, and there's no reason to doubt him being town at this stage.

Anyone else could be scum, but the one who I have the strongest feeling about right now is Fosters. I know I been ultra critical considering everyone (including me) but there's just too many comments he's made that has made me doubt his town affiliation.

Vote Fosters

^^^

Driving that bus already? I would've thought you'd have Bennett do that.

I posted that bolded bit trying to provoke a reaction. Let's see which of the two did just that....

Yes me saying I'm keeping my word is so weak sauce that I'm featured in two voting post and last night's write up that makes it seem me and someone else was targeted and potentially protected last night. Real smart there, Mike. Makes me raise an eyebrow towards you with your sudden hard on for me.

I said I'd do exactly what it is I said I would do, and that's what I am doing. If I were to go against what I said I was gonna do I'd be voting for the person I've been the most suspicious of this game.

It's great this game has sparked into life but could people stop quoting quotes within quotes it's impossible to follow.

Ducking Quoteception

I'd love a Bennett lynch right now, even over a Fosters one.

[GM Franchise]

Josh being town sort of makes me almost certain He's town.

Kirk has played a, rather unique card, and there's no reason to doubt him being town at this stage.

Anyone else could be scum, but the one who I have the strongest feeling about right now is Fosters. I know I been ultra critical considering everyone (including me) but there's just too many comments he's made that has made me doubt his town affiliation.

Vote Fosters

^^^

Driving that bus already? I would've thought you'd have Bennett do that.

I posted that bolded bit trying to provoke a reaction. Let's see which of the two did just that....

Yes me saying I'm keeping my word is so weak sauce that I'm featured in two voting post and last night's write up that makes it seem me and someone else was targeted and potentially protected last night. Real smart there, Mike. Makes me raise an eyebrow towards you with your sudden hard on for me.

I said I'd do exactly what it is I said I would do, and that's what I am doing. If I were to go against what I said I was gonna do I'd be voting for the person I've been the most suspicious of this game.

It's great this game has sparked into life but could people stop quoting quotes within quotes it's impossible to follow.

Ducking Quoteception

I'd love a Bennett lynch right now, even over a Fosters one.

And you ignored my post completely. Then why aren't you voting Bennett? If you believed that you'd change your vote in this post. C'mon, man!

Vote: Powers

[GM Mike Powers]

Not responding to you is vote worthy? Mmkay.

Josh being town sort of makes me almost certain He's town.

Kirk has played a, rather unique card, and there's no reason to doubt him being town at this stage.

Anyone else could be scum, but the one who I have the strongest feeling about right now is Fosters. I know I been ultra critical considering everyone (including me) but there's just too many comments he's made that has made me doubt his town affiliation.

Vote Fosters

^^^

Driving that bus already? I would've thought you'd have Bennett do that.

You're on the Fosters wagon, too. Let's not forget about that either.

That's not the greatest point you're making here. I'm saying Fosters is scum - hence my vote. I was trying to draw out his scum mates, and I feel like I did with Bennett.

I'm happy to vote for either, cause I think both are scum. This is difficult to understand?

[GM Franchise]

Not responding to you is vote worthy? Mmkay.

Josh being town sort of makes me almost certain He's town.

Kirk has played a, rather unique card, and there's no reason to doubt him being town at this stage.

Anyone else could be scum, but the one who I have the strongest feeling about right now is Fosters. I know I been ultra critical considering everyone (including me) but there's just too many comments he's made that has made me doubt his town affiliation.

Vote Fosters

^^^

Driving that bus already? I would've thought you'd have Bennett do that.

You're on the Fosters wagon, too. Let's not forget about that either.

That's not the greatest point you're making here. I'm saying Fosters is scum - hence my vote. I was trying to draw out his scum mates, and I feel like I did with Bennett.

I'm happy to vote for either, cause I think both are scum. This is difficult to understand?

You also said Bennett was scum even more so than Fosters or implied it to be precise. What the fuck is it then? I think you're scum more than them with all this fence sitting crap I'm reading right now. That gives you the excuse to flip a vote on either one of them and make it seem like not a big deal. You're playing all the angles and I don't like it which is why I'm voting for you over them. Note buying the bullshit excuses about your vote being on Fosters instead of Bennett at all.

[GM Mike Powers]

Fence sitting? The fuck you going on about? Look at Doug yesterday, THAT is fence sitting. I hate to break it to you but I only got one fucking vote man. I've identified 2 players I think are scum and I'm voting one. I'm struggling to see your problem with this.

[GM Lucas]

VOTE COUNT
Fosters - 3 -(Oldfield, Powers, Doug)
Kirk - 1 - (Bennett)
Powers - 1- (Franchise)
Doug-1-(Eli)

NOT VOTING-EVERYONE ELSE

WITH 8 ALIVE IT TAKES 4 TO LYNCH. YOU HAVE UNTIL MONDAY FEBRUARY 14TH, 12PM EST TO REACH A LYNCH. DO NOT POST AFTER DEADLINE. ONCE A LYNCH IS REACHED, IT IS REACHED.

[GM Franchise]

Fence sitting? The fuck you going on about? Look at Doug yesterday, THAT is fence sitting. I hate to break it to you but I only got one fucking vote man. I've identified 2 players I think are scum and I'm voting one. I'm struggling to see your problem with this.

My problem with you is you're saying one thing and going for your second option over the one you like better which is a huge fucking red flag to me. No, fence sitting is saying oh, I think this person is a better vote than someone else but voting for the other person. I don't give a fuck how many votes you have, you said you'd love a Bennett lynch better than a Fosters lynch yet you're still voting for Fosters. You literally have no credibility at all and your word in this game means shit if you're not going to practice what you preach. You literally leapfrogged everybody else in the game as a suspect in my mind after the bullshit you're doing. If you were voting for Bennett instead of Fosters all of that bullshit that you're saying would be a lot more believable than it is now. Not buying it all.